Tag Archives: review

Review, SciFi

Doctor Who: The Blood Cell by James Goss

2 Comments
Doctow Who Blood Cell
Doctor Who: The Blood Cell by James Goss

Doctor Who: The Blood Cell by James Goss is one of three new Doctor Who stories being released this Tuesday September 9th, 2014 by Broadway Books, which feature the Twelfth Doctor. I  received this eARC through Blogging for Books via Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review. I was excited to get this book since I am a die hard Doctor Who fan. At the same time, I was not sure what to expect since at the time of this writing, only three episodes with the twelfth Doctor have aired. I even found myself reading it in Eleven’s voice, even when trying to keep Twelve’s in my head. I do wonder a little if putting these out now was in fact strategically smart with the momentum from the new season, or if it is too early since we had not yet had time to really get to know the latest regeneration or really see him as The Doctor.

Refocusing on the book, we join the Doctor in this adventure in a prison set in a remote asteroid. Very little is know upfront, we have no idea why the Doctor (Prisoner 428) is in this prison, what terrible event he is looking to avert, or where exactly Clara and the Tardis are. He obviously does have an agenda. Let’s face it, the Doctor almost always does.  What we do knows is that he believes that something bad is going to happen and if the Governor of the prison does not work with him and release him, something bad will happen and people will start getting killed, which for the record, Clara shows up and petitions the Governor claiming the same thing. With the Doctor, these statements generally hold true, even if he is not aware of some impending doom. Since the Governor does not believe him, the Doctor decides he will just have to continually break out until they get the point. I cannot get too much deeper into the plot without spoilers, but needless to say, the prison is having problems and while everyone blames the Doctor, he wants to figure out what is really going on.

What is interesting about this narrative is that it is written in a first person point of view and not that of the Doctor or Clara, but of the Governor. This is somewhat of a change from other Who novels.  It does offer a unique perspective that I can only think of one or two TV episodes that approached it this way. The plot itself was not bad. It seemed in line with what could be an episode this season. I have seen a number of other reviewers criticizing the ending, but I saw no problem with it. In all fairness, it was an ending I would come to expect from the current direction of the show. It actually felt a bit like the Satellite Five and later Gamestation episodes. Was it an amazing, epic Doctor Who adventure? Not particularly. Was it an awful adaptation of the Doctor? Certainly not. It was a fair and decent story. There were funny moments, suspenseful moments; it was Doctor Who.

One area I am normally very critical of is characterization, but novelization of a running character is really hard to fit into a regular square box. If you read the book, you should be well familiar with the character. The author should not be defining the main characters in a Doctor Who novel. They are already near and dear to the readers. Your only job is not to butcher them. What Goss did need to do was define the other characters which I felt he really did do a good job with. Also, since this is early in the 12th Doctor’s run, he did have to work with a personality we do not know much about yet and I think with that in mind, he fared quite well. The Doctor’s little quips and obliviously unflattering comments to Clara fit in with the first few Capaldi episodes. As does the spoon. I do not know if it was intentional, but a spoon does come into play in Season 8 Episode 3 as well as in this novel, which gave me a bit of a chuckle. The way it come up here though was something I may have expected more from the Tenth Doctor.

All in all I felt the book was pretty good for a Doctor Who story. As I said earlier, it is neither the worst nor best I have come across, but it was entertaining and engaging. I flew through it. I will admit it was tough to put down, I finished it in two days. It took a lot from the show and worked with a new Doctor that I honestly do not know enough about yet to criticize the portrayal. With that, it is considerably more difficult to rate. My gut says that it is a 3.5/5. If you are a Doctor Who fan, it is worth a read. Just do not expect a “Blink” or “A Good Man Goes to War”.

 

Review, SciFi

Dark Eden by Chris Beckett

1 Comment
dar-eden
Dark Eden by Chris Beckett

Dark Eden was first published in 2012 which soon earned its author Chris Beckett a British Science Fiction Association Award  nomination for Best Novel that same year. It then went on to win Beckett the  Arthur C. Clarke Award for Best Novel. In 2013 Broadway Books, an imprint of Crown Publishing, acquired the US rights. It was published here earlier this year. I received a review copy for this US publication in exchange for a fair review.

This novel is a science fiction and dystopian story. The story takes place on a planet, or more likely planetoid, called Eden. I say planetoid for two reasons; first, there does not seem to be a central mass or solar system that it orbits. There is no natural sun or close by star. Secondly, the planet appears to be fairly small. Several generations ago a few people from Earth took off into the unknown, followed by police, and landed on Eden. While some attempted to return home, two of them stayed, waiting for the possibility of Earth to return to get them. In the meantime, the two who stayed began their own family and started populating their new home. Jump to present day in the book, there are over 500 people living on Eden, all in the one area where their ancestors first landed. These humans are living on a truly alien planet. Their light and heat come from trees with hot sap pumping through them. The animals somewhat resemble the creatures of earth, yet are wholly different.

The people make the best of what they can in their little piece of this alien planet. The whole community of every human living there is called Family, while subgroups have sprung up named mostly after things around them such as Redlantern and Spiketree. These groups have their own areas within Family. The society is governed by both the group leaders as well as a council presiding over all groups. They have lived this way since the first two, Tommy and Angela, taught them.

One teen, John Redlantern, sees things a bit differently. This main character does not understand why things have not changed. He feels that the traditions are stifling them and not allowing them to grow and reach the level of those who came from Earth. John and small group of friends wish to expand Family. Traditionalists are not happy with this idea and controversy spreads. The story switches tracks from idealism to adventure on this still mostly unknown world.

There is a whole cast of unique individuals. Beckett give you a good taste of all of them, though not in major depth. I can say that while I understood most of the characters, I cannot say that I really liked any of them. Not that I did not like how the author wrote them, I did not like their personalities. I suppose that says they were developed enough to have unlikable characteristics. I started out liking John and the way he saw the world. I later found that I very much disliked him. I began to see past his altruism and saw something else. I also really liked Tina Spiketree at first, but I stopped being able to. Other characters were meant to be hated, and you do in fact hate them as you read.  While the characters were developed, I just personally have trouble getting fully immersed in a story where there is nobody to really relate to.

Another interesting thing was the language. They spoke English, since Tommy ad Angela did. They know of London, Brooklyn, television, electricity, and so on. There was no way to truly understand these things, but they had vague ideas. They however spoke about it in a manner similar to when you are teaching a three year old and they say things how they hear them. The names and words come out in hybrid English/baby talk. That is how a lot of the words in the story were. It makes sense. Slang develops in all cultures and vowel shifts, etc. It is as if you are teaching a child to say things, however you do not correct them, so their mispronunciations are passed down for generations. It worked in the story so it did not bother me most of the time. Occasionally I wanted to yell at the characters to pronounce the words properly, but that is just me. I will even point things like that out at the office.

The story was fairly interesting. The concept of stranded earthlings making their home on a distant and strange alien world is a great science fiction concept. It felt like a Lord of the Flies meets Lost in Space. OK, two classics there so it is not really a negative statement, but I felt that it could have been taken so much farther. I realize that this is only the first book in a series, with the next one slated for release in 2015, I believe. The first story did not jump out at me and make me want to continue though. I tend to have bad luck with award winning novels. Maybe I expect too much going in, or maybe I just have a completely different taste that award committees, but I tend to not love these lauded novels as much as I want to.

The book was not bad, 3/5 in my eyes. I did not love it, but I did not hate it. It seemed right in my wheelhouse, but just did not live up to expectations. Again, Dark Eden was an OK book, but I felt it was too lackluster considering all of the praise. I wanted to love it, instead I just did not mind it.

Fantasy, Review

City of Stairs by Robert Jackson Bennett

1 Comment
city of stairs cover
City of Stairs by Robert Jackson Bennett

City of Stairs was an interesting book (which is due to be released on September 9th, 2014 by Broadway Books, a Crown imprint) that immediately intrigued me. I had not really been aware of it leading up to the promotional stage and though I know of Robert Jackson Bennett, I did not actually know much about him or his writing. This is actually the first chance I have had to read his work. When I looked at the description it immediately stood out as something I needed to request. The story takes place primarily on a colonized continent. The Continent was formerly a world power which wielded its’ own pantheon of gods. The gods are now long gone and a smaller island nation has colonized the Continent. More or less at the center of the Continent is the city of Bulikov, our main focal point. An even with certain political and legal implications brings our main character, Shara, over to Bulikov, and that is just the first few pages.

In town with the credentials of a diplomat  assigned to the local embassy sent to investigate recent events, Shara is actually about as far from a political player as one working for thier govenrment can get;, she is one of Saypur’s top operatives on the continent. Her true job is less diplomatic politician and more undercover spy. What sounds so far like a geopolitical drama evolves into a world with a unique magic system and a strong fantasy based story. Religious extremists, divine miracles and unexplainable events cause Shara and her associates to believe that these long gone gods may not be as gone as everyone seems to think. The plot really escalated quickly and refocuses several times. There is drama, magic, twists and plenty of action. More than enough for any fantasy fan.

I really appreciated the level of characterization and descriptiveness the author used. The characters were given not only depth, but layers. I really liked how the the layers were teased out over the course of the book, slowly revealing more and more about them and their history. I felt like I had a strong understanding of many of the main characters at the end and a really nice glimpse into their pasts and their motives. I am a sucker for strong characterization and Bennett certainly gave us that. It was not only the characters that were given full back stories, but also the regions, the deities and political structure. The world building was fantastic and unique. It bordered on fantasy world building and urban fantasy world altering. It does not end there either. The descriptions were detailed and vivid. One particular scene stands out where Shara is cooking while discussing some rather in depth Continental history. The detailed descriptions of her preparations intertwined in her conversations felt so casual yet was extremely well done, completely taking me into to scene where i could absolutely see her standing there crushing garlic and slicing meat. I do not know why that stuck with me so much, but I was completely impressed with it.

If you cannot already tell, I really, really enjoyed the book. The action scenes were great, the world building was very well done and magic system was interesting and unique. I have not talked about Sigrud at all in this review so far, but you will love Shara’s “secretary” and travel companion. I do not know if there is anything in particular that I  can point out that I  did not like. I have to give City of Stairs 5/5.  I absolutely recommend pucking this up. I would even go as far as saying to pre-order it, it liked it that much. I am not claiming that this is the most revolutionary book I have read and it will change your life. It was however damn good and fairly unique and I am confident that most SFF fans will love it. The novel was a very well balanced book. I hope we see something else in this universe. I know I will have to pull some of Robert Jackson Bennett‘s other works after this.

Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher, through Goodreads in exchange for a fair review.

Fantasy, Review

Half a King by Joe Abercrombie

Leave a comment
Half a King cover
Half a King by Joe Abercrombie

Half a King , the recent novel by Joe Abercrombie, is the author’s first real foray into the world of Young Adult and the first book in his new Shattered Sea series. I have mixed feelings about YA in general, but with Joe Abercrombie as the author, I was going to dive in either way. On one hand I feel that YA is really flooding the market, especially in the Fantasy genre. On the other hand I love that it is out there and there is a good base to bring younger people into the literary world. I will not go into my YA feelings in any more depth right now, I prefer to take a book for what the content is, rather than how it is marketed.

At the heart of the story we have our main character, Yarvi, the second son of the King and Queen. Yarvi has no real air of royalty and is in fact studying to become a minister, having no interest in the royal life. Yarvi is young, weak and had a deformed hand. In a family and culture which prides itself on strength and warfare, he knows where he stands. Unfortunately his plans are upended and he is forced to take the throne. Whilst beginning to settle and accept a life he never truly wanted, Yarvi is betrayed in usurper’s a grab for power. He swears an oath of vengeance and to reclaim the throne he wished never to have.

Regardless of the YA billing, this is still very much an Abercrombie book. It may have been conceived for an audience younger than the average Abercrombie fan, but the loyal fans can still love this novel and get a real sense that the author has not compromised in writing it. There is still a gritty and grim feel to this book. There is enough death, blood and violence to get that familiar ‘Lord Grimdark’ feel. It is a classically styled fantasy-adventure novel. I think it is good for any age… well, maybe anyone above middle grade.

Although it does go above the YA classification, it does keep strongly to the YA formula. A young protagonist, usually teenage, either becomes a leader, or is thrown into a tough situation (usually a combination as it is here) and has to work through it and grow up quickly. Not to say that I do not enjoy the books, but too many really do fall into that narrow scope. The only other slight criticism I had was the “twist” as it has been labeled by other reviewers. I don’t know how much of a twist it really was. From early on I though “hey I can tell this is going to happen,” and I was just waiting on the reveal. It could be that I was expecting a twist and this was the most logical theme, or that I’ve watched to many bad-guy of the week TV shows that I always look for things. Many others have written about their shock at the twist and I am sure that added to their enjoyment. I, on the other hand, felt that it was a fairly blatant thing and it even helped me better understand one of the secondary characters a bit better as I was reading.

The novel as a whole was a very well done classic story by Joe Abercrombie. It is certainly a must read for any fan and certainly a recommended read as an introduction to this author for any fantasy reader who is not yet a fan. I give Half a King 4.5/5 with the only caveat for me being the predictability. I think being surprised or have a more unexpected ending would have made it that much more enjoyable and moved it well into the 5/5.

Review, SciFi

My Real Children by Jo Walton

Leave a comment
My Real Children by Jo Walton
My Real Children by Jo Walton

Published here on May 20th 2014 by Tor, and coming to the UK in August, Jo Walton brings us her tenth novel, My Real Children. This is the story of a woman, Patrician Conway, who is living in a nursing home with dementia. Her biggest problem is that she seems to be living two lives. Not only does she feel that she is in a different place on different days, but she distinctly remembers two different pasts.  The book dives in to those pasts. It has taken me longer than I had hoped to get to this review, considering I had gotten this from the publisher back at BEA. I even managed a signed copy, though not personal, it was pre-signed, which is still really nice.

The major thing that I have noticed about Jo Walton is that she really is a great writer. The other thing is that her writing almost fits as well, if not better into the “Non-fiction” general category than it does into the genre specific Sci-Fi and fantasy. She writes truly wonderful prose, but she does hover that genre line by having just enough to qualify. Among Others for example has a light fantasy hint to it (though I maintain that girl is crazy), but mainly it was about a weird girl from a dysfunctional family, and her books. My Real Children is really a story of two alternate histories and the way these lives played out based on an early decision. The science fiction is really in the fact that these are alternate histories. Within those histories there are further sci-fi aspects which are more of something ancillary to the plot. It also builds rather slow to this, with the first of these sci-fi aspects emerging about half way through the book.

Again, this was very nicely written and it was a nice story, though it did leave me fairly sad. It was not even the proper ending that did it, rather events leading up to the end. Jo Walton‘s greatest strength is really her development of the main character, and I do not mean solely in this novel. You really feel that you understand the main characters, both versions of them here. Having a strong character development is something that always pulls me in as I get a sense that this is a real person behind everything. I do not know if all of the characters were so developed though. I felt like I got a taste of some of their personalities, and some I did not feel I knew more than their names.

Other than the actual writing, what I loved about this is that you can feel real love for the people and places. I cannot even explain how badly I want to visit Florence right now or get a gelato. What I did not love was the overt agenda. I thought the overly liberalized agenda was way to strong. I am not commenting on the agenda itself, I do not have a problem with it directly, my problem is they way that it felt too obvious, too in my face, and it took me out of the story. I completely felt like I was being lectured about feminism, anti-war sentiment and disarmament. What if you already drank that particular kool-aid and are on board? It still feels like it is being shoved down your throat. A certain degree of it absolutely helped the plot, but I think it went on more than it was needed.

I put this novel at a 3/5. I enjoyed the story and the writing, but it really did start off slow for me. There were plenty of wonderful part as well as things that yanked me out of that world. It was a nice balance, but simply balancing does not really shift me into loving something or not. I may have brought it up another star if I was expecting a general dramatic story, but I tend to like genre driven stories, and I did not feel that is truly lived up to the genre it was billed as. I also did not love the ending. It did not offer the closure I wanted.  Is this novel worth a read? I think it is, sure. As long as you have the correct expectations going in.

Fantasy, Review

The Truth Is a Cave in the Black Mountains

Leave a comment
The Truth Is a Cave in the Black Mountains (Enhanced Multimedia Edition): A Tale of Travel and Darkness with Pictures of All Kinds
The Truth Is a Cave in the Black Mountains (Enhanced Multimedia Edition): A Tale of Travel and Darkness with Pictures of All Kinds

This review is going to be a little different. This is mainly because the item I am reviewing is a bit different. Back in August of 2010 Neil Gaiman read one of his short stories at the Sydney Opera House in a multimedia event. Images were created from the prose and displayed on a screen while a string quartet played to the mood of the story. Last week I found out that this was going to be recreated at Carnegie Hall and that really excited me. Unfortunately I was not working in the NYC office that day, I was working out of HQ on LI and working late. I did the next best thing and bought the published version which came out June 17th 2014. While this story itself has been available online, Neil Gaiman only just released a multimedia version. That, as much as the “book” is what I will review.

Before I continue I have a word or warning to anyone looking for this hybrid version: read device support from your vendor. For example, the Kindle version only works on Kindle Fires and iOS devices. It does not work entirely with standard e-ink Kindles, Android apps or the PC. You can still read it, but not hear it. The same goes for the Nook edition, Nook devices only. I ended up with the Google Play enhanced eBook so that I could see it in color on my Nexus tablet and listen to it. That, obviously, is the version I will review.

The format of this special enhanced, multimedia… thing… was nice, unique, but could use refinement. It was different for sure. I did like the images with the story. It had a feel like a graphic novel at some points, specifically when text balloons were incorporated in the scenes.  One thing I do enjoy when reading is creating the scene in your head, but it is nice to know that you are picturing what the author intended, so the guided images were a pleasant change. The audio included was a mixed experience as well. On one hand it felt like an read along audio book with Neil’s reading from the original event. I will discuss my thoughts on audio books at a later time, but I do like the idea of it having a combined presentation. I can see where some people might not love the idea, but both reading and listening are options and not mutually exclusive. The other side of the audio is that behind the reading is the string quartet. On some level I wish there was a separate track, but I realize that without being timed to the reading, it loses the effect. My major criticism is that the audio stops playing if you do anything. Go to the page that continues the text still being read and the audio stops. You cannot follow completely along. This may be different on other editions, but I cannot confirm. Overall, it was a nice experience, but that did bug me a few times.

On to the story. I am, admittedly, a biased Neil Gaiman fan. I know absolutely nothing of the story other than it was done by MR. Gaiman and that was good enough for me. Since it is a short story that can be read in about 90 minutes I really cannot discuss much without spoilers. In essence this is set on the Scottish countryside  where one man enlists the help of a guide who has a known reputation, to find a cave in a hidden island filled with treasure. The story is absolutely fantasy based, with several twists, and really any interesting tidbits will give the story away. I considered and deleted even a single adjective a dozen times while writing this, trying to decide if it gave too much away.

While it was fairly interesting, I felt that the story was flat. It started very slow and mostly progressed the same way. There were a few big moments, but not enough to really make the story. The end felt right, but a little rushed considering how much the story felt teased out. There were some images as well as the cover that made me think it would be freakier than it was. The story was fine, but it does not really live up to what I have come to expect and love out of Neil Gaiman. Perhaps that is unfair, to judge on the author’s merits, not the sole story, but I honestly feel my rating would be the same either way. I would rate this 3/5 considering all aspects of the multimedia experience as well as story content.

Though Neil was already here in NY and in San Francisco, he can still be seen this week in the UK, in London on 7/4-7/5/14 and Edinburgh on 7/6/14. See his site, http://www.neilgaiman.com/, for details.

Review, SciFi

The Martian by Andy Weir

Leave a comment

Originally self published in 2012, Andy Weir‘s The Martian was picked up by Crown publishing (a Random House subsidiary) and was released just a few months ago. The story is about Mark Whatney, an American Astronaut on a Mars expedition. There is nothing particularly historic about this mission, it is not the first and there are already more planned. What makes this a special situation is that Whatney is left behind when his crew leaves the planet and he is presumed dead. The botanist/engineer has to figure out how to survive on a dead planet with nothing but a couple of months worth of supplies.

I was fairly backlogged at the time this was released (or re-released rather), but I am very glad that I finally got around to reading it. I have to say that while I like and support self-published authors, I do find myself sticking mainly to major SF/F publishers (and almost exclusively reviewing them) as those publishers are more experienced and have a good idea of what works. Some self published stories are amazing (Wool anyone?), but the questionable content can be difficult to sort through. It is for this reason that I am thankful to Crown. Had they not found The Martian, I may never have either and this book was too good to miss.

I loved this book. You can stop here and go read it, I’ll wait. I really cannot find any way of just objectively describing the book, I can only tell you that it was one of the best Sci Fi books I have read in a long time. Mark Whatney is a humorous, sarcastic smart-ass, who talks like a real person, not some stereotypical scientific genius. My kind of person. If there was a situation where my reaction would have been “Holy Shit!” you can bet that is exactly what the character said. From the first page to the last sentence that character does not disappoint. Looking at the SciFi angle, there is really tons of science in it. Much of the book seemed plausible when you see of all of the science, engineering, calculations and modern actual technology. The reader is taken through all of this and can really feel the amount of thought and work that must have been put into writing it. There was no trace of impossible technology from the distant future, most of this could be done right now. Even the peek in to NASA’s internal workings felt authentic, though I am sure any actual NASA staff might not agree. It was funny, well written, rarely predictable and continually fun and enjoyable. It was as perfect a SciFi book as I could ask for.

I easily give this 5 a full 5 stars and recommend this to any Science Fiction fan. I also really look forward to reading whatever comes next from Andy Weir. I cannot say enough good things about this book. If you read it and hate it, well, first stop listening to me, I may not be your best barometer. Second start reading another genre.

Check out Any Weir’s Website and The Martian Page for more.

Preview, Review, SciFi

The Word Exchange by Alena Graedon

Leave a comment
The Word Exchange
The Word Exchange by Alena Graedon

Disclaimer: I received this eARC in exchange for an honest review. Also, as this was an ARC, any content is subject to change by time of publication.

The Word Exchange, debut novel by Alena Graedon, is a new and quite unique book. The novel is being published by Doubleday and will be release on April 8th. The story is set in the near future when printed publications are a distant memory, held on to by only the most dedicated enthusiasts. Electronic devices reign and in the US, the Meme is king. While most of us are already constantly connected through our mobile devices and high speed data plans, Memes take it to the next level. Not only are they connected to everything and constantly using sensors to asses the user’s environment, they are also intuitive. Not in the way my Android has an “intuitive interface”, no, they actually can sense what you want. They can order for your, hail a cab, or even look something up for you without asking it. This includes looking up words in the interactive pay-per-word dictionary (well, sort of) the Word Exchange. There are even even accessories that stream data to the user, some of which can further link to your mind. Some even go as far as an implanted chip.

Anana Johnson (our main character) works with her father, Doug, at the North American Dictionary of the English Language (NADEL) in New York City. Doug is working on finishing the third edition of the NADEL for the upcoming publishing date. As a linguist, editor and general print and book supporter, Doug is not fond of Memes. More than that, he does not trust them. It is more than just seeing the electronic devices as competition, as they are also developing an electronic version of the NADEL. Doug’s behavior and attitude begins to grow more paranoid about the devices and warns Anana about them. he also preemptively give her a course of medicine in case of an upcoming sickness.

Soon after this Doug’s erratic behavior increases, he mysteriously disappears. With her father missing, Anana tries to track him down with the help of her co-worker and her father’s protege, Bart. In looking for any sign of Doug or where he may have gone, Anana stumbles into dangerous situations, subversive conspiracies and the Diachronic Society, a secret(ish) society which shares many of her father ideals and is clearly anti-Meme and against it’s parent company, Synchronic. On top of all of that, a word-flu manifests, with a combination of flu like symptoms as well as symptoms affecting the infected person’s speech (aphasia). The story is a mixture of Sci-Fi, mystery, thriller and somewhat dystopian.

The characters, especially Anana and Bart are very well developed and you get a nice sense of who they are. The writing is also very well done and the tone is unique. It is written from two perspectives, one being Anana, the other being Bart’s journal. I tend to appreciate stories with multiple perspectives as it adds depth to both the reader’s ability to interpret the events as well as an insight into how each character perceives the same things in different ways. My criticism of the writing style is somewhat difficult. I loved the way it was done, but the language seemed a little much. The author appears to have tried to find more obscure words in a thesaurus and really upped the reading level. I get it, I really do. After finishing the book I truly appreciated the value of doing this. The irony of having to look up works while reading on my Kindle was not lost on me and even caused a few errant chuckles. The language lent both to the story and the style. There was motivation there for the author, but I do see this as something that will really divide readers. Certain people will be scared off or turned off with the overly large or unknown words. In the end it works, quite well actually. I do see this as being a barrier for some people who might otherwise like this story.

The plot itself was very good as well. I have always been more into the Sci-Fi and fantasy aspects of stories and less into the mysteries, but as a plot device the mysteries surrounding both Doug and the word-flu worked well. The progression and pace of the story flowed very well in my opinion. I think that many of the allusions and points centering around technology and the loss of printed material is very valid today (have you seen how few bookstores there are in NYC now?).  As is the idea that people do not feel the need to learn things when they can access everything instantly instead. Much of this foreboding content made this whole idea seem very real. I have relatives in school who do not even have text books. Entire schools districts are using nothing but a tablet.

There are some things that even with the suspension of disbelief are a little hard to accept. The way the word-flu spreads is well though out an explained… to a point. After that point of plausibility, it gave me pause. I try not to nitpick, but it bothered me a little that such a well thought out story could have that flaw. The one other thing that got to me where some of the dates. This is obviously set a few years in the future, but the year is not explicitly mentioned. Regardless, there are years mentioned concerning events in various characters’ pasts. I am not sure the years work. The time may work out, but it made me stop and think every time. Also, I am curious what this does to the value of the book in say five years. Would it then be marketed as alternative history? It might be comparable to if Orwell wrote Nineteen Eighty-Four in the late 1970’s.

In the end the overall story was very enjoyable, entertaining and absorbing. These traits more than anything are really what is important when looking for a good book. A lot of things that I was wondering about came together in the end which made many things richer upon thinking back. I really like the characters and related to both them and the main thematic ideas. While there were some flaws, everything has flaws, the question is how noticeable of distracting they are. I would give this book a 4/5. There were only a few issues I had with the book, but I really liked it very much. I was not something I sacrificed sleep over, not able put down, but  it was something I really liked from beginning to end. I recommend this book without hesitation. I really wanted to go out and but some printed books after this, but something about reading on the kindle and being able to look up words just felt too right.

Be on the lookout for it on shelves and beamed to your devices ob April 8th. To read more about this novel check out the following links to: the publisher’s page (Doubleday), the distributor (Random House), Alena Graedon’s Facebook and Goodreads.

Fantasy, Preview, Review

Elder Scrolls Online

Leave a comment

So first off, this is my first non-book post. Normally I would not do this, but since it is a preview, I thought some book fans might like to hear about it before it comes out. I felt that the content is strongly fantasy themed and there is a large crossover between fantasy readers and gamers.I received beta access without any expectation from the developer of any review (in fact, at the time I was under an NDA). The exchange was while I got to play the beta, they got the the results and feedback they needed. I write this with an unbiased and honest view.

Exactly one week ago the final scale beta for Elder Scrolls Online (ESO) completed. Luckily I had the opportunity to participate in a few of the test sessions. These beta weekends have been going on for several months, in conjunction with Zenimax’s own internal testing. The sessions I was involved in were primarily meant as stress tests to see what their servers could handleand what needed to be tweaked for public release. Up until the second to last beta there was a strict nondisclosure agreement (NDA) preventing us from writing any reviews or previews. Now that the testing is done and I have a free moment, I would like to share some details of the game. I took some videos and screenshots and while they came out well, I felt they they were not helpful in describing the game-play, so for now I will let my words do their thing. If you really want to see any of it, just ask me. There are many hours of ESO on YouTube already and tons of screenshots floating around. Reddit even has and ESO subreddit.

First, there has been some decent changes between betas, so I am not sure how much of this will hold up between now and release time. The starting area actually changed in the last beta, which I felt was a positive change, but it also shows that anything I talk about here is no guaranteed to be in the final product. The main thing people seem to want to know is whether this is more like Skyrim or like WoW. Well, I don’t play WoW, so I can only guess. It really is somewhat unique though. The PvE does feel like an Elder Scrolls game… ish. It obviously is different from Skyrim in many ways, but the landscapes, exploration and general content make you feel at home in an Elder Scrolls world.  The creatures, both enemy and benign, are call backs to previous games and help you settle into the familiar lore. The biggest differences for me are the magic system and (the elephant in the room) the multitude of other players surrounding you.

Unlike Skyrim and Oblivion, magic is not a weapon slot item. it it a quickslot action. This give it a more MMORPG feel. Most RPGs use a system like this, but it does take something away from the ES spirit a little. The people around surprisingly are not as distracting as i though. Even playing the lone wolf, not playing with friends or finding a group, other players can be helpful. Exploring a dungeon, even above your level, is enhanced when players can watch each others backs. Loot is given to all participant who kill an opponent so there is no scrambling to pick it up, and in PvE you cannot harm other players. The one bad thing is certain objectives are world based and not instanced so you are sometimes scouring for a bit before you find something other players did not take/use/kill.

PvP is a different animal altogether. This is more like Guild Wars 2 with an Elder Scrolls edge. There is still a good deal of exploring and questing to be done, but the real meat of Cyrodil is the Alliance war. Combat is faction based and you can only fight opposing alliances. You fight for control of keeps, for various assigned objectives, and for possession of Elder Scrolls.  The factions are a large central point in this game. There is the Ebonhart Pact with the Argonians, Dunmer (Dark elves) and Nords. The Daggerfall Covenant with Bretons, Orcs and Redgaurds. Finally the Aldmeri Dominion with Altmer (High Elves), Bosmer (Wood Elves) and Kajit. The races are bound to the factions, unless you ordered the Imperial edition where you can choose what group to be in. You also get an addition race: Imperial, and some other extras. Each groups have completely different game-play. They exist in different areas of Tamriel, the quests are mostly unrelated, though guild quests are fairly similar, and your home area in Cryodil (PvP) all depend on what faction you choose.

As in all games of this type, the race and class strongly impact your character’s abilities and grow, more so than in some other Elder Scrolls games. The skills are class and race specific, not available elsewhere. In Skyrim it mostly have you boosts and affinities, in ESO, skill trees are unique.  I created a number of alt characters to test this, and it really makes a difference. Dragonknights make good fighters or tanks, Nightblades are generally assassins and rogues, Templars can be tanks and healers and sorcerers are, well, mages. The abilities are very different. Guilds and PvP also give you access to other skills trees that unlock based on your progression in those aspects. I would say to play around, because my usual character choices did not feel right. I went a little out of what I generally liked and really enjoyed my play times as they synergy of skills really spoke to my play style. While I felt my usual go-to Dunmer Assassin to be underpowered and frankly a bit boring, the Altmer Mage, I created when the Ebonheart quests got stale do to bugs my first session, quickly became my favorite and I stuck to it through the remaining sessions.

Now, this was a beta test, so there were a lot of bug. No, really, a LOT of bugs, frustrating at points. Some quests were fatally broken and I had to play areas way above my level, giving rewards I was not powerful enough to equip, just to progress. Walls disappeared, characters did not spawn, I fell through the sky a few times. I am hoping they have a lot of fixes at work on the private test servers, or hidden up a sleeve, because it was a bit rough, and with early release a week away, it would be a lit of work from what I last saw to be ready for launch. Don’t get me wrong, I loved the game and if you are OK with the $15/mo fee, I highly recommend this as a really nice MMO with fresh look and feel. I just hope they have it polished a bit more for paying customers.

I could bore everyone to death listing the details of the game that are out there, but there are many sources of this already. I just want to share my experiences. Typically I am drawn to single player games. To me they tend to have a richer story. Also I rarely have enough time to get anywhere near as good as serious core gamers. I am not quite a casual, but time is becoming more difficult to find for gaming and single player games move at your own pace. I could put hundreds of hours into a game, but it may take me more time to do it than many others, I spent all of my time in the first beta and half in the second beta only playing quests. I liked the quests quite a bit. They were very much like typical Elder Scrolls type quest, with only the slightest generic RPG feel. There really were not man, kill 50 of these, find 20 of those, style quests which have plagued games recently. I thought I could be content with PvE for a while. That being said, the PvP is really fun. I felt like it could not give proper feedback on the  game without trying everything and I was glad I did. When you find a large group rush attacking a keep, it is really quite entertaining. The siege weapons are really a nice touch as well. These experiences are really more immersive than I would have thought. Enemies are also scaled. When you may be level 20, fighting a level 50 enemy, it is still do-able.

Crafting, I did not love. I didn’t hate it, but it was nowhere near as good as in Skyrim. I did fairly well, got up to decent levels, but I can’t see spending as much time smiting or crafting in this as I did in Skyrim. Same with enchanting, really different, and not nearly as enjoyable. Again, not terrible, just not as good.

The group dungeons and Skyhooks are another great addition, but they really require groups. Groups are easy to find or join, but this is a big departure from Elder Scrolls play and really a more typical MMO type of activity.

Overall I was please with the game. the bugs were frustrating, but it was a beta, they are expected. I have high hopes for this game. I would recommend it to ES players looking for a more expansive world, or MMORPG players looking for something fresh. If you have any questions about the game, let me know. I will have a new book write up later this week as well.

Fantasy, Review

Words of Radiance by Brandon Sanderson

Leave a comment
Words of Radicance
Words of Radiance by Brandon Sanderson. Click for more information

Words of Radiance is the second installment in Brandon Sanderson’s  Stormlight Archive epic fantasy series, published by Tor. This novel picks up where The Way of Kings left off. Those of you who have read the first book know that it ended with many unanswered questions and tons of foreshadowing. With the first in the series having been published in 2010, it has been a long four year wait pondering the ways everything could play out. On March 4th, we finally got what every Sanderson fan has been waiting for.  Since this is the second novel in the series, I will not go through a summary of the world as I assume anyone looking to read this should have read the previous one. If you have not, I strongly encourage it, it is worth the read. I also will not go into much of a recap in case anyone reading this has not read Way of Kings, though there may be spoilers from that book here.

I think most people would agree that Sanderson is an expert both in characterization and in creating magic systems. While most of the characters were established in the first book, they are further expanded here. Some of the bridgemen who were more ancillary characters see stronger stories and deeper roots. Where the character depth really shines is with Shallan. This is absolutely her book. Don’t get me wrong, Kaladin and Dalinar are still major part of this story. I simply mean that while Way of Kings really focused on Kalidin, his back story and his growth, Words of Radiance does the same for Shallan. She really transforms in this book from the way we perceived her in the previous novel. Both her past and her development make you see a different side, which is that of a much stronger, and frankly bad-ass, young woman.

The magic system also shows some growth from where we left off. We more or less understand the significance of stormlight in the magic through not only Szeth, but Kaladin as well. Much of Jasnah’s and now also Shallan’s research expands upon both our and the charter’s understandings of this system. You will see more of it and in a much more developed sense. The other aspect of this system that we see a deeper understanding of is the nature of spren. These strange, semi-natural, yet somewhat mystical creatures do have origins as well as parts to play, as we have seen with Syl and Kaladin.

Another great things about this is story is that it never gets stale . There are perpetual turns which are largely unexpected. Even the expected ones tend to keep you on your toes. The many shifting vantage points of the same situations is another great strength here. You can see the same events happening from multiple perspectives. It really puts an interesting spin on things wen you see the different ways an event is seen as well as how different characters are viewed. I wish I saw this more often. The only really complaint I had with the stories was the same one I had in Way of Kings. I can’t say that I really love the Interludes. There was only one that I really enjoyed, that of Eshonai. I know that most (certainly not all) of these come together at the end, but I tended to find myself pushing through them to get back to the meat of the story.

Though is book is huge, like the previous one (1088pp for the Kindle version, this is why I have not posted in a while), I still manged to read it in less than a week. I could not put it down. I would get home from work, read it within an hour of settling down, and then got to bed way later than I should because I just couldn’t stop. To me, that separates a good book from a great one. I know I am slightly biased as a fan, but I honestly felt this was phenomenal. I easily give it 5/5. I just hope we do not have to wait nearly as long for the third Stormlight Archive novel.

You can find out more about this book, series and author by checking out the corresponding pages at GoodReads, as well as Brandon Sanderson’s own web page.